Which rules apply to a med spa photo
A before-and-after photo on your site is two things at once. It is a picture of a real person, who either agreed to be shown or did not. It is also an ad for a medical procedure, and ads for medical procedures have their own rules.
A Medical Board of California page, carried over from its January 2007 newsletter, calls med spas that offer medical procedures marketing vehicles for those procedures. Put plainly, the gallery on your website is advertising for those procedures.
Below is what the law asks of the photo and of the release, then a gallery setup that keeps the two together. Nothing here judges any image. It is only about what has to sit next to one.
What California says a before-and-after photo must show
Section 651 of California's Business and Professions Code says the before and after views have to be comparable, with no favorable poses or lighting. It also says the photo has to name the procedures performed on that patient, in a prominent spot and easily readable type, and carry a statement that the same results may not occur for all patients.
In practice, comparable means the two shots are taken the same way. Same angle, same distance from the camera, same light, same plain background. If the after shot was taken in a different room under a brighter lamp, the pair fails that test before anyone looks at the face.
The easiest fix is a photo spot that never moves. Mark the floor where the client stands, keep the lamp in one place, and use the same camera or phone every time.
The results statement belongs right next to the image, not in a footer three scrolls away. Write it once and use the same wording under every pair, so nobody has to remember it.
Read the text of section 651 with your gallery open, or better, ask your attorney to.
When a client photo counts as health information
The HIPAA Privacy Rule lists full-face photos and comparable images among the identifiers that have to be removed before health information counts as de-identified. So a face in a before-and-after pair, taken as part of a treatment, is the kind of detail that ties health information to a person.
HIPAA does not cover every business with a camera. It covers a health care provider that sends health information electronically in connection with a covered transaction, such as an insurance claim. Whether your practice is covered is a question for your attorney, and worth asking this month.
Even if your practice is not covered, the HIPAA release rules below make a sound floor for any photo release. A release that meets them is clear to the client and clear to whoever runs the gallery after you.
What the photo release has to say
If your practice is covered by HIPAA, it needs a signed authorization before it uses or discloses protected health information for marketing. A before-and-after gallery is there to bring in new bookings, so treat it as marketing.
The rule spells out what that authorization has to hold. Three parts matter most for photos:
- A description of the information it covers, written in a specific way. For photos, name which photos, from which visit, and where they may appear.
- An expiration date or an expiration event. Pick a real date, so nobody has to guess later whether the release still holds.
- A statement that the person has the right to revoke it in writing, and how to do that.
Your attorney can check your form against the full rule, 45 CFR 164.508. Have them read it before anyone signs it.
A gallery that keeps the release next to the image
Often the images sit in one folder and the releases somewhere else. That gap is where trouble starts. Nobody looking at the website can tell which photos are still allowed to be up.
One vendor flags each photo as clinical only or approved for marketing. Another vendor's help center says photo consent carries over to future visits, and the client can withdraw it at any time. Your website gallery should work the same way. Each published pair carries these fields with it:
- Release signed: the date the client signed the publish consent.
- Expires: the date or event the release names.
- May appear on: the places the release names, such as the website gallery only.
- Caption: the procedures performed on that patient and the results statement.
- Status: live, expired or withdrawn.
Before a pair goes live, someone checks two things. The before and after shots match in pose and lighting. The photo is flagged as approved for publishing, not only for the chart.
When a release expires, or the client revokes it in writing, the status changes and the image comes down from the site that day. Set a reminder a month before each expiration date, so the image comes down on time and not whenever someone happens to notice.
If your site has a content system, these can be plain fields on each gallery entry, and the page can hide any entry whose status is not live. If your gallery is a page builder with no fields, keep a short sheet with one row per image and the same columns, and link each row to the scanned release.
What to do
- Pull every before-and-after photo on your site into one list, with the client and the date of each.
- For each photo, find the signed publish release. If there is none, take the photo down today.
- Check that each release names the photos, gives an expiration date or event, and explains how to revoke it in writing.
- Next to every pair, name the procedures performed and add the results statement.
- Retake or remove any pair with mismatched poses or lighting.
- Add a publish checkbox to intake, separate from the chart photo checkbox.
- Ask your attorney to read the release form and to tell you whether your practice is covered by HIPAA.
If you would rather have the release fields built into your gallery, see websites for med spas: you own the code and the accounts from the first day.