A membership is a monthly charge first
A membership or a prepaid package looks like a menu item on your site. Underneath, a membership is a card charged on a schedule, and the card is the part that breaks. When a renewal declines, what matters is what your booking or billing tool does next.
The tools don't all do the same thing. Boulevard puts the membership in a past-due state and retries the charge on its own. Square, when it cannot charge the card on file for a subscription, emails the customer an invoice with a link to pay. Those are two different jobs for your front desk, so it helps to know which one you have.
What each tool does when a card declines
Boulevard
When a renewal payment fails, the membership goes past due, and Boulevard retries the charge on what its help page calls a front-loaded schedule. If the retries don't work, the only way back to current is a new card on file.
Square
Square's subscription documentation says that when its attempt to charge the card fails, Square sends the invoice to the customer's email address with a link for making a payment. That email is how Square tells the member. Check that the email on each member's profile is one they actually read, not an old work address.
Stripe
Stripe Billing can retry failed subscription payments automatically. It can also email customers when a payment fails, when a card expires or when a payment method needs an update. Stripe describes both on its revenue recovery page, and both are worth confirming in your own account rather than assuming.
New cards, expired cards and cash members
Banks replace cards that expire or are lost or stolen, and the saved card goes out of date. Stripe tries to update a saved card on its own when the bank issues a new one. In the United States, that works for most American Express, Visa, Mastercard and Discover cards issued there. Most is not all, so the expired-card email from Stripe Billing is the backstop for the rest.
Cash is the other gap. In Boulevard, a member who paid the first month in cash has no card on the membership, and can add a credit card through the client portal before the next payment is due. The easy moment to get that done is at checkout, on the member's own phone, before they leave.
What a member should be able to do on your site
Two things: change the card, and cancel. Stripe's customer portal lets a customer update their payment method. It also lets them cancel a subscription, either right away or at the end of the billing period. In Boulevard, the client portal is where a member adds a card, and clients can see their vouchers there too.
Your site's job is to make those pages easy to find. A plain link called "Manage membership" on the membership page and in the footer does it. Nobody should have to call to find out how to change a card.
Cancelling matters in California for a second reason. California's Attorney General said on September 4, 2025 that a person who signed up for an auto-renewing plan online must be able to cancel it online. The alert ties that to a law amended effective July 1, 2025. The same alert says a business must send customers an annual reminder about their auto-renewing plan. Read the alert itself, and ask your own lawyer how it fits your plans.
What the front desk needs on screen
A past-due member should be spotted before the appointment, not after. Boulevard has a Memberships Past Due report that lists every past-due membership, how long it has been overdue and why the payment failed. Open it each morning next to the day's bookings, and the desk knows who to ask for a new card when they check in.
Packages need a different screen. In Boulevard, the vouchers from a purchased package appear in the Wallet tab on the buyer's client profile. The Wallet tab groups vouchers by the membership or package that granted them and shows the date each was received and when it expires. That is the screen to open when a member asks how many sessions they have left. Boulevard's packages help page carries no clear date, so check that your own account looks the way the page describes.
If your tool does not show the desk these two things, past-due members and package balances, that is the gap to fix first. A custom app can sit on top of your billing tool and show them on one screen.
What to do
- Open the Memberships Past Due report in Boulevard this week, or the matching list in your own tool, and call the members on it.
- In Stripe, confirm that automatic retries and the failed-payment and expired-card emails are switched on.
- Put a "Manage membership" link on your membership page that goes to Stripe's customer portal or Boulevard's client portal.
- If members can join online, make sure they can cancel online, and put the annual reminder on the calendar.
- Ask every cash member to add a card in the client portal before their next payment is due.
If you want this built into your site, see websites for med spas; a written plan comes before a price.